PART.II.thought
We forget that pains and miseries are only the symptom of a disease
but the the disease lies elsewhere …
This is the first part of an introduction to PART.II. The text may seem to be away from architecture. It is the profession that has gotten distanced with architecture. We are taking a few steps back to find our way back.
In PART.I.Goal I noted that the mind is described as having four components in the Indian Traditional Knowledge System (ITKS) and its component yoga. Manas, buddhi, ahankara and chitta, correspond respectively to thought, intellect, ego and conscious mind. Thought is distinguished as only a part of mind. We are examining the role of thought in this differentiated context of mind.
PART.II is about thought. In the modern tradition, thought is the faculty that is considered to have brought humanity to its advancement and how we gain personal success. As a sign of higher consciousness, thought is broadly considered to be what makes us different from all the other creatures. Thought’s towering reputation supports the perception that technical creations are complete. We take as proof that the results of thought are rational, logical, with outcomes that ‘work’.
We are going to consider a POV of the architectural profession that we construct by applying research in the spiritual practice of rajayoga and its broader knowledge system. According to yoga, a part of the ITKS, there are four components of mind. They are manas (thinking), buddhi (intellect), ahankara (ego, intentionality and drive) and chit (consciousness). These are not concepts, nor are they the output. They are living bodies that continue with our physical body. The integration of these components suggests that our world could not be controlled at all by thought alone. Engaging this structure in the context of the mind will guide us in understanding technology’s role in architectural practice and the evolving profession.
Our orientation to the thought component of mind can be sampled through the common feeling that machine-based AI might somehow become equivalent to us. Many people are concerned — or excited — that AGI is destined to supersede us. The AI that is being introduced now is powerful and is dangerous as any powerful tool or weapon might be. But if thought is not whole in itself and is an isolated component of mind, while machines may replicate the outcomes of thinking, those machines will not have the mind’s complete capacity. AI will not supersede humanity, although it could be used to eliminate our society and culture, and ‘replace’ humanity with something else that would most likely be inhumane.
We adapt to machines and their knowledge production faster than they can be made like us. If we don’t notice when the outcomes of computing or AI are skewed or wrong, it is because they mimic our thought, which we consider whole. This contributes to the appearance of AI’s successes.
AI and automation enhance the value and the danger that a person, corporate entity, government institution, product, process or weapon already has. Not only aggressive leaders pose danger. The seemingly innocent scientists, technologists, engineers and bureaucratic functionaries who go on with powerful developments are often isolated from their responsibility to humanity and Nature. Anthropomorphizing machines, including machine-like design process, is part of the social and cultural realm. It is a choice. The responsibility for results due to the manifestation of our thoughts formed in all manner of tools and weapons, rules and systems, corporations and places, remains with people and people’s intentions. Unravelling the complexities of technology in human culture is key to halting that power’s undoing of humane culture.
Being Realistic About Progress
We have been hooked on ‘progress’ through technology for a century. When technology suddenly accelerated on a curve, it eliminated a lot of work and freed up our time very quickly. My grandmother transitioned from one full washday in a special room each week to a few hours every now and then. Progress appeared to be an automatic good until that short reign began to erode in the 1960s. Much of the new approaches was proving toxic, either directly with leaded gasoline and a host of new chemicals, and indirectly with DDT’s ravaging effect on birds’ eggs.
Despite progress, today millions of people still starve every year and billions live a starving life if they do not. We are not careful that the benefits of technology are justly attained, that they are justly distributed. Millions of tons of rice and wheat rot in storage or are routinely destroyed for market advantage or in war. Market ‘mechanisms’ take food spoilage as an expense with transport and storage into ROI calculations that may include artificial scarcity. Efficiency is based on narrow task orientated outcomes measured by what spreadsheets can carry, usually in terms of currency.
This is not passive; we actively avoid summing up. The ramifying complexity is used to generate more capital gains. Human and environmental harm is justified for wealth generation, and remediation or compromise create more ‘wealth’ generation. Homelessness, the stress of work, information overload and social media, both licit and illicit drugs are opportunities for solutions that can lead to more business. Much thinking is going on while this happens. Our orientation to solving problems can be put in question because we always create more of them. Given the power we have and the capacity to think through any problem, it is clear that something is amiss.
Harm is complex. Concealed behind the targeted result, harms do not immediately reveal. Harms are most often discovered after deployment at scale, such as DDT’s deployment and social media. We are only beginning to see that what we have been creating during the Machine Ages has been so damaging that the betterment we got may not result in a net gain for humanity.
All of this may seem quite bad. Some of you may think that these paragraphs have been unreasonable or unfair, and that I am pressing this button too hard. But it’s OK. What we can do about it and what all of this will allow us to gain is so profound that it dwarfs it all.
No matter how brilliant, thought and thinking are ambiguous in defining the quality of life. The use of technology is not a technological issue. It is dependent on political, social and cultural values. A lack of ability to do right by humanity and Nature is lack of unity, lack of good will, and the basic values that we call ‘humane’. Invoking the concept of ‘mind’, makes it possible to feel how the effort and its results imply serious deficiencies and great opportunity.
Thought in Architectural Practice
The egregiously poor quality of urban environments is part of this. The role of the intentional environments we make in this Modernist disaster is vast. The measurable widespread plight of hundreds of millions of people lacking basic needs for dwelling and our displaced hundreds of millions are part of this. Lack of wellbeing through poor and overpriced homes and the squalor of most urban environments is then magnified by the lack of architecture almost anywhere now. The homeless and displaced are caught in miserable public environments that manifest depreciating quality of life.
I am not saying that the architectural profession is responsible to creating the horrible conditions we are all aware of. An architect will almost always provide a better result. The manifestation of our thought formed as the environment is everyone’s doing. But the architectural profession is implicated by the ancient presence of architecture that we all know of. The responsibility for results always points at the architectural profession. The profession’s governance, its paradigm, and each practicing architect has resulted in a lack of agency, a lack of power, and that architecture is not called for.
The professional’s work is realized through a technological system that gathers the matter of nature, which we then consider humanity’s property, even humans of each other. Illness is created by this thought-out exploitation of the natural world. The destruction of the biosphere is mirrored by the misery of much of human life, while our thought process seems unable to deal with the scope of our responsibility. Practicing architects are complicit in conceiving and preparing our vast interventions in the world. The work may be competent, but we need to put the approach that we are part of on trial.
Breathless announcements that problems of housing will be solved by factories, prefab, and other forms of mass production, newly including 3-D printed homes, have not provided meaningful results over the past hundred years. Taking on the vast destruction of our earth’s life nominally with ‘climate change’, addressing it as with zero-energy, zero-carbon and other abstractions, fails catastrophically at scale and in scope. Even as automobiles and many other products have benefitted from mass production, housing does not, and the environment does not. Automobiles and appliances are transient and detached from their context. Their context is cultural, and connection to place is a linkage and flexible. A mutually sustaining relationship with the environment, the biosphere as life, is less possible with mass production. Architecture and architects in practice have consistently shown that they cannot proceed further. This project will provide some answers to that.
Architects are at the interface of human welfare and the earth’s welfare. No other profession is wholly orientated to this interface, although the environment is also processed by many other groups in silos. The nominal potential and scope of architecture puts the technology of design and planning, and the construction and professional systems that we employ in question due to the poor results we see. Removing the solace of invoking progress, which has left the same things undone for generations, we may face our goal sincerely.
This disaster of our intentional environments, the plight of millions lacking basic physical needs and homes, and the poverty of private and public spaces and the natural environments that we plunder, need to be far better addressed for an architectural profession to rightly claim ‘professionalism’ and to reclaim the leading role, if we are the only profession with that responsibility. Without us, the relationship is devastated as the profession visibly loses its social real-ness and value.
The wealthy are far less vulnerable, having the means to isolate themselves and to repair damage, while displacing their pollution to other places. There are few wealthy people. The wealthy do suffer as we all do from the poor environments they have funded, just like everyone, when they cannot insulate themselves. Moreover, the confusion between luxury and architecture leaves many wealthy patrons with deeply harmful environments. Mental issues are legion for the poor and for the rich.
Returning to thought, while it is common to focus on progress, the ignorance necessary for thought to re–territorialize ‘what is’ must be considered as well. ‘Progress’ does not remove ignorance in principle. Solving individual moments of ignorance does not remove it. The implicit need for ignorance, which is around us like air, is a resource for ‘discovery’. Knowledge–production accords with balancing ignorance with gaining information. That ignorance is an infinite human resource is natural, but not necessarily a good thing to enhance. It proves the existence of modes of knowing other than thought solutions.
Our supposition is that architecture is integral to consciousness and its wellbeing. Practice must paradigmatically bear human awareness and aspiration for the environments we prepare to fully serve our consciousness and its wellbeing. Solutions and technology are means to provide this, but that is not what they are. Developing that supposition will expose our dependence on nurture and the generosity of our humane nature to evolve with and within nature and its generosity.
Finding Progress in Practice
Architecture has become an extra in our cultures. This is in large part due to the inability of the architectural profession to make a case that has a grip on the true value of architecture. We manifest technology as the form environments around society and its cultures, politics and laws, bound up with issues of knowledge and ignorance, crime, piety and insanity.
Although the profession itself does not pose architecture as an extra, it also seems loath to claim the actual profound human need for it. Professional associations retain that need as implicit importance in a technical way to allay the very difficult interface of common business practices with profound welfare responsibilities, transforming architecture’s professional value ‘cache’ into the elite form of production we see today. ‘Sincere’ architectural intent is generally lacking in practice as the profession defers to this orientation.
The weakening of the architectural profession is evident. There is a relationship between this weakening and that misalignment. Architecture is left substantially undefined, to allow some of us to proceed in spite of this low valuation and poor support.
Architects are lucky that the term ‘architecture’ is universally understood to exist and to be of benefit. We are grateful that it continues to exist widely in our cultures and across humanity. This sustains the profession and its aspiration as we continue not focusing on what that is very well at all. It is being thought (out) so minimally that it is satisfactorily called ‘design’, even by architectural professionals!
Architecture is strangely out of step with its own mandate. Even uncannily. The professional’s mandate to develop and inclusively incorporate technology has become a dependence on technology to define practice. This dependence has put the profession in a detrimental position. Along with generations of doubling down on intensive collaborative interaction with trades and services, the profession is clearly in contradiction to those. The work to smooth that over is functional day to day, and builds a wall against architecture every day.
This is a symptom of an opportunity. It is a sign that humanity is growing out of the current professional service paradigm. If the architectural profession is inherently divergent from currently destructive trends, then disunity with useless or destructive (use of) thought to locate it in the wider context of mind would strengthen the profession.
Architectural value is an awareness of duty that reveals what is essential at a locus. Mind’s component intentionality, discipline, and will, i.e. ego (ahankara) and consciousness (chit), come into play. Progress toward a new paradigm for the architectural profession is possible. How we think life’s process and nature’s process in practice conceals architecture. The outcomes in the technicist professional model of practice reveals the profession’s future.
The next article introduces a path to alternatives grounds, rather than alternative solutions, toward practice that will reveal architecture.


